Journal · From Medium

My Son’s Favorite Toy Story Character Isn’t Woody or Buzz Anymore

What Toy Story 5 taught me about storytelling, strong female characters, and why audiences follow great heroes.

What Toy Story 5 taught me about storytelling, strong female characters, and why audiences follow great heroes.

When I walked into Toy Story 5 with my nine-year-old son Chase, I expected to spend the ride home talking about Woody, Buzz Lightyear, and whatever new adventure Pixar had cooked up.

Instead, Chase surprised me.

His favorite character wasn’t Woody.

It wasn’t Buzz.

It was Jessie.

And what struck me wasn’t that Jessie is a female character.

It was that Chase never mentioned that fact at all.

He liked Jessie because she was brave.

She took action.

She solved problems.

She carried responsibility.

She kept going when things got difficult.

In other words, he liked her because she was the hero.

That simple observation taught me something important about storytelling.

Kids Don’t Care About the Debate

Adults spend a lot of time debating representation, demographics, and who should lead a story.

Kids don’t.

Kids are brutally honest.

They follow the character who earns their investment.

Chase didn’t walk out of the theater saying:

“I liked Jessie because she’s a girl.”

He walked out saying she was his favorite because she mattered to the story.

She made decisions.

She faced challenges.

She carried the emotional weight of the movie.

And that’s exactly what audiences have always responded to.

Great characters.

The Character Who Earns It

One thing I loved about what Pixar did with Jessie is that she wasn’t simply placed in a leadership position.

She earned it.

The emotional core of her story wasn’t about power.

It was about worth.

She kept showing her value even when she wasn’t always sure she had any.

That resonates because almost everyone wrestles with that question at some point.

Do I matter?

Am I enough?

Did I make a difference?

The characters that stay with us are usually the ones who answer those questions through growth.

Not perfection.

Growth.

That’s why audiences connect.

What This Taught Me As A Writer

Watching Chase respond to Jessie made me realize how much my own writing has evolved.

Years ago, I might have been hesitant to build a story around a female lead.

Now some of the most important characters in my creative universe are women.

Melody in Mid City Dreamers.

Jasmine in Mid City Dreamers: Love and Hustle.

Autumn in the Vox LeRoy music universe.

And Lisa, who plays a major role in the future of Mid City Dreamers 2.

The lesson I’ve learned is the same one Pixar reinforced:

The audience doesn’t care whether a character is male or female when the character is compelling.

They care whether the character earns their emotional investment.

That’s it.

No Villains, Just Humans

Another thing that stood out to me about Toy Story 5 was how mature the conflict felt.

The story wasn’t built around a traditional villain.

Nobody was trying to destroy the heroes.

Nobody was evil.

Instead, multiple characters wanted what they believed was best.

They simply disagreed about how to get there.

That’s a much more interesting conflict.

And honestly, it’s a philosophy that has influenced my own work.

One of the upcoming songs in the Vox LeRoy catalog is called “No Villains, Just Humans.”

The title reflects an idea I’ve become increasingly interested in as a storyteller.

Most people aren’t villains.

Most people are simply trying to navigate life, relationships, fear, ambition, love, and disappointment with the tools they have available.

Sometimes they hurt each other.

Sometimes they misunderstand each other.

Sometimes they make mistakes.

But that doesn’t automatically make them villains.

It makes them human.

That’s a more complicated story.

And usually a more honest one.

The Future Belongs To Great Characters

When the original Toy Story came out in 1995, I was fifteen years old.

Thirty years later, I sat in a theater watching my son experience the franchise from an entirely different perspective.

For my generation, Toy Story was often about Woody and Buzz.

For Chase’s generation, Jessie can be the sheriff, the leader, and the emotional center of the story without anybody thinking twice about it.

And honestly, that’s pretty cool.

Not because somebody lectured him.

Not because somebody told him what to think.

Because Pixar gave him a great character.

And he responded to greatness.

As a filmmaker, that’s a lesson I hope I never forget.

Audiences don’t follow demographics.

Audiences don’t follow trends.

Audiences follow characters who earn their hearts.

Jessie earned Chase’s.

That’s why she was his favorite.

And that’s exactly how great storytelling is supposed to work.

⸻

About the Author

Justin Charles is a filmmaker, writer, musician, and founder of Anaomi Entertainment. He is the creator of Mid City Dreamers, Mid City Dreamers: Love and Hustle, Vox LeRoy, and other original projects exploring storytelling, relationships, music, emotional safety, and human connection through film and art.

More from the Journal